American
$9.90+
Ham and bologna with Swiss, American cheese, and classic toppings.
“My husband and I just discovered this place on a whim. Great subs they seem to steam the buns for hot subs.. highly recommend the Reuben sub it was fantastic”

From deli meats to vegetable and cheese fillings, subs at Brother John's Sub & Sandwich in Toccoa are available for pickup.
Order onlineAmerican
$9.90+
Ham and bologna with Swiss, American cheese, and classic toppings.
“My husband and I just discovered this place on a whim. Great subs they seem to steam the buns for hot subs.. highly recommend the Reuben sub it was fantastic”
Chicken Salad Sub
$9.90+
Chicken salad, Swiss, lettuce, and tomatoes fill this sub.
“Best subs around!!!”
Ham & Cheese Sub
$9.90+
Ham and Swiss with mayonnaise, mustard, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
“Great local business. Great subs. Get there early for lunch. They stay busy, pizza sub is real good.”
Italian Sub
$9.90+
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, and vegetables fill this sub.
“If you’re in Toccoa and desiring a sandwhich, show this place some love!! I had the Italian sub drizzled with their Italian dressing and it was delicious! The bread was also perfect! Give this place a try, you won’t regret it!”
BBQ Ham Sub
$9.74+
Ham, BBQ sauce, provolone, and onions fill this hot sub.
“The best sub shop around been eating there 10 or 12 years”
Beef Pepper Melt Sub
$10.45+
Spicy beef, onions, American cheese, BBQ sauce, and jalapeños.
“Best subs in toccoa”
Pizza Melt Sub
$9.74+
Salami, pepperoni, spicy marinara, onions, and provolone fill this sub.
“I’ve been eating here for 30 years, and the New Owners and Management have done a Fantastic Job with keeping the Quality and Originality on point, still after 30 years, in my opinion there’s no better sandwich on the planet! Give them a try you won’t be disappointed, get yourself a Pizza melt atw, add Black Olives, (Large). Gah my mouth is watering!”
The Nancy Jo Club
$10.34+
Turkey and bacon with melted Swiss, mayonnaise, and fresh toppings.
“Supremely good subs”
Ham & Cheese Sampler
$4.95
Half a small ham and Swiss sub with vegetables and condiments.
“Great subs and salads!”
Pizza Melt Sampler
$4.40
Half a small sub has salami, pepperoni, marinara, onions, and provolone.
“Such a great place for subs. I visit whenever I am in the area.”
Roast Beef Sampler
$4.40
Half a small roast beef sub comes with Swiss and fresh toppings.
“Subs were great. I recommend the Big Ben atmosphere is awesome service was great. Didn’t have to wait long for my food. Definitely coming back.”
Turkey Sampler
$44.40
Half a small turkey sub with Swiss, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
“Best sub place in town! It’s very clean, great atmosphere, friendly service & the subs are amazing!! Shop & eat local!!”
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich serves subs with fillings from smoked turkey and Swiss to homemade tuna salad. Vegetable-filled rolls feature radishes, cucumbers, carrots, mild peppers and black olives.
Italian Sub layers ham, salami and pepperoni with provolone. Reuben Sub pairs thinly sliced corned beef with brown mustard and sauerkraut. Pizza Melt Sub has spicy marinara, onions and melted provolone.
Visit Brother John's Sub & Sandwich in Toccoa for pickup, dine-in or delivery. The Trilogy lets you pick three deli meats and your cheese, including pepper jack, with wheat or white sub rolls available.
Brother John's Sub & Sandwich offers kid-friendly options, including Kid's Bologna Sandwich and Kid's Cheese Pizza.
Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.